Papers · Articles

The Dealer Doesn't Check ID: Drug Laws as Body Violation, the Safety Paradox, and the Case for Pharmacies Over Car Parks

A. C. Applebee, L. N. Combe · 2026

Abstract

The global prohibition of psychoactive substances, now exceeding five decades of implementation, has failed to achieve its stated objectives of reducing drug use, improving public safety, or protecting public health. This paper synthesises evidence from pharmacology, public health epidemiology, political philosophy, and health economics to construct a comprehensive argument for evidence-based drug policy reform grounded in three interlocking pillars: body sovereignty as an ethical foundation, the safety paradox whereby illegality manufactures the very dangers prohibition claims to prevent, and risk-proportionate regulatory frameworks drawn from successful international models. Drawing on Portugal's 25-year natural experiment in decriminalisation — which reduced drug-induced deaths from 80 in 2001 to 16 in 2017 (an 80% reduction), collapsed HIV transmission among people who use drugs from 52% to 7% of new cases, and increased treatment uptake by 60% — this paper demonstrates that health-centred approaches produce superior outcomes across every measurable dimension.

Download PDFCite